top of page

5 HR Questions Small Business Owners Should Ask Before Making a Decision

kaitlynjanzen5
Sep 28
4 min read

You have an employee situation that needs to be addressed.


Maybe an employee has started arriving late regularly. Maybe their performance has changed. Maybe there has been a conflict between employees, or you are wondering whether you can change someone's schedule or end their employment.


You know you need to do something, but you are not quite sure what.


For many small business owners, this is where HR gets complicated. Without a dedicated HR department, you find yourself searching Google, having a late-night session with Chat, asking another business owner what they would do, or hoping the answer you find online actually applies to you with BC legislation.


Before making an employment decision, there are five HR questions worth asking.


Man looking up HR Questions on his phone.
Man looking up HR questions on his phone.

  1. What exactly is the issue?

Start with the facts.


It is easy to describe an employee has having a "bad attitude", being "unreliable" or having "performance issues". Those descriptions may reflect what you are experiencing, but do not tell you exactly what happened.


Instead, ask yourself:

  • What specifically happened?

  • When did it happen?

  • How often has it happened?

  • Who was involved?

  • What was the employee expected to do?

  • Has the expectation been communicated clearly?


For example, rather than documenting that an employee has a poor attitude, you might document that an employee interrupted a coworker repeatedly during a meeting on a specific date, despite being reminded about respectful workplace communication.


The more specific you can be, the easier it becomes to understand the actual issue and determine what should happen next.


This is one reason clear expectations are such an important part of good HR foundations.


  1. What do our existing policies or agreements say?

Before taking action, take a look at the documents you already have.


This might include:

  • An employee agreement (or offer letter)

  • Employee handbook

  • Job descriptions

  • Performance expectations

  • Previous written communication with the employee


Your policies and agreements should help provide clarify about what is expected and how certain situations are handled.


This is also why having practical workplace policies in place before you need them can be so valuable.


A handbook does not need to be hundreds of pages long to be useful. For a small business, the goal should be to have policies that address the areas that actually matter to your workplace and that your employees and managers can understand and follow.


  1. Are there employment standards requirements I need to consider?

This is an important question for any BC employer.


Before making an employment decision, consider whether BC Employment Standards requirements may apply to the situation.


Depending on the circumstances, this could involve things such as:

  • Hours of work

  • Overtime

  • Vacation and vacation pay

  • Statutory holidays

  • Leaves

  • Payroll requirements

  • Ending employment


Employment standards are only one part of an HR decision, but they are an important one.


The fact that something seems reasonable from a business perspective does not necessarily mean that there are no employment standards requirements to consider.


If you are unsure, it is better to check before acting rather than trying to fix a problem after the fact.


  1. Have I documented what has happened?

Good documentation is one of the foundations of good HR.


Documentation does not mean creating a complicated report every time something happens.


It can be as simple as recording:

  • What happened

  • When it happened

  • Who was involved

  • What was discussed

  • What expectations were communicated

  • What the employee said

  • What the next steps are


The goal is to create a clear record of what actually happened.


Documentation can be especially important when an issue continues over time. It helps you see whether there is a pattern, whether expectations have been communicated and whether previous conversations have taken place.


It also helps prevent situations where months later you are trying to remember exactly what happened and when.


It can be done on a piece of paper that you put in the employee file, or if you are on the go, sending yourself an email that you file later on.


  1. What are my options?

This is the question I would encourage business owners to ask before jumping straight to a solution.


You may have more options than you initially think.


Depending on the situation, the next step could be:

  • Having a conversation with the employee

  • Clarifying expectations

  • Providing coaching

  • Providing additional training

  • Creating a performance improvement plan

  • Seeking HR advice

  • Seeking legal advice when appropriate


Not every employee issue requires the same response.


The right next step depends on the circumstances, the employee's history, your policies, the applicable employment legislation, and other factors.


HR Does Not Have to Be Complicated


Small business owners have enough to manage without becoming an HR expert overnight.


You do not need to know the answer to every employment question. What you do need is a way to recognize when a situation needs attention and a reliable place to turn when you are unsure what to do next.


Sometimes it means reviewing your policies.


Sometimes it means getting advice about an employee situation.


Sometimes it means having someone help you prepare for a difficult conversation.


And sometimes it means knowing when a situation needs legal advice.


The important thing is not to make an important employee decision based on a quick Google search or Chat or an assumption about what another business did.


Practical HR Support for Small Businesses


At Janzen HR, I work with small businesses throughout the Fraser Valley (and beyond) to provide practical HR support without the corporate jargon or one-size-fits-all approach.


Whether you need help with workplace policies, employee issues, documentation, performance concerns, hiring, onboarding, or simply have an HR question you are not sure how to handle, you do not have to figure it out alone.


Sometimes the best place to start is simply a conversation.


Have an HR question? Get in touch with Janzen HR to talk through your situation.

Janzen HR provides HR consulting and support for small businesses in Chilliwack, Abbotsford, Mission, Agassiz, Harrison and Hope and beyond.




 
 
 

Comments


© 2025 Janzen HR. Powered and secured by Wix

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
bottom of page